This Is Why Government Health Care Won’t Work

In the past, people who hiked in the wilderness were aware of its dangers and prepared themselves accordingly. If they got in trouble, they relied on themselves to get out of it. But technology changed that.

Personal locator beacons, which send distress signals to government satellites, became available in the early 1980s, but at a price exceeding $1,200. They have been legal for the public to use since 2003, and in the last year the price has fallen to less than $100 for devices that send alerts to a company, which then calls local law enforcement.

OK, so hikers can now avail themselves of emergency services at the touch of a button, which is life-saving for someone who gets seriously injured on a back-country trail.

But the unintended consequence has been that the definition of “emergency” has been dumbed down to what would previously have been called  “inconvenience.” One group of hikers in the Grand Canyone hit the panic button because the water they found “tasted salty.” A woman in California hit the panic button because she was afraid of thunderstorms. In these cases, and others, emergency teams had to be dispatched by helicopters at a cost of thousands of dollars.

The same thing happens with socialized health care. If individuals are no longer responsible for their health care costs, things like common colds and hangnails become medical emergencies.

Also, experts say that the existence of emergency locator beacons make inexperienced hikers more willing to take risks than they would have been otherwise. The same will be true when health care is socialized.

And forcing insurance companies to cover people with pre-existing conditions is going to be disastrous to, because now people can sign up for health insurance after they are diagnosed with cancer, or AIDS, and as a result, everyone else’s premiums will have to go up to cover them.

By understanding human nature, and seeing how it plays out vis-a-vis situations like personal locator beacons, it is possible to predict the unintended consequences of well-intentioned policies.

Lost in the woods? Just scramble emergency services.

Lost in the woods? Just scramble emergency services.



Filed under Uncategorized

3 responses to “This Is Why Government Health Care Won’t Work

  1. robert

    Odd; I’ve lived in Britain and the UK, working in hospitals in both places, and the place where people use the emergency service for stuff they should be responsible for was the US. It was poor folk with complications of untreated diabetes, and I guess they had to wait until it was pretty serious before they’d get seen on medicaid, so I guess it probably wasn’t just hangnails.

    But I haven’t seen much of the stuff you’re talking about here. When it does happen it gets written about a lot and everyone gets cross and it all dies down.

    In general, people who are writing about socialized medicine haven’t looked very hard at a country with socialized medicine. It has its problems, but not the ones you’re talking about here…

  2. Cylar

    We’re rapidly entering an age where none of us is responsible for his own actions, but where we’re all responsible for the actions of everyone else.

  3. The Doktor

    Stop! Stop! Stop! Stop! All of this logical reasoning is giving me a Leftist headache! (That’s where the truth starts a throbbin’ that won’t stop.)

    Utopia just costs a lot more than the usual Health Care coverages. Didn’t you read that in Rules For Radicals???

    Doktor Pillpusher

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s